With the announcement of “1923” Season 2, the upcoming “1944” prequel, and swirling rumors about Kevin Costner’s future on the show, it’s been hard to keep track of what’s fact and what’s speculation.

Initially, rumors suggested that McConaughey would be brought in to replace Kevin Costner as John Dutton in the main “Yellowstone” series. However, it quickly became clear that McConaughey would not simply step into Costner’s shoes.

Instead, as talk of the original “Yellowstone” series ending gained traction, speculation shifted to a new spin-off series starring McConaughey as the lead. This spin-off would potentially feature other familiar faces from the franchise, such as Kelly Reilly and Wes Bentley, and possibly introduce McConaughey as a distant Dutton relative—perhaps a descendant of Spencer Dutton from “1923.”

Adding to the excitement, Kurt Russell’s name was also floated as a possible lead for a “Yellowstone” project, fueling theories that he and McConaughey could play father and son, ushering in a new Dutton dynasty. The idea of two A-list actors taking the reins from Costner was well-received by fans, who felt it would help maintain the show’s high profile and devoted following.

However, statements from those close to the production began to clarify the situation. Kevin Costner’s lawyer dismissed the idea that Costner was ready to walk away from “Yellowstone,” emphasizing the actor’s commitment to the show.

Wes Bentley, who plays Jamie Dutton, also downplayed the rumors, suggesting that such speculation happens every year but the series continues regardless. These reassurances made it seem unlikely that McConaughey would be replacing Costner in the main show.

Given these developments, it appears that if McConaughey joins the “Yellowstone” universe, it will not be as a direct replacement for Costner, but rather as the star of a new or existing spin-off. The most likely candidate is the upcoming series “1944,” which would serve as a prequel set during World War II.

In this scenario, McConaughey could portray the father of John Dutton, managing the Yellowstone ranch while grappling with the challenges of post-war America and possibly suffering from PTSD after returning from Europe. The addition of Kurt Russell as Spencer Dutton or another Dutton relative would further enrich the story and appeal to fans.

There’s also a possibility that McConaughey could join the long-awaited “6666” (Four Sixes) spin-off, set on the historic Texas ranch. This modern-day series has been in development for some time, and casting a major star like McConaughey could give it the boost it needs.

He could play the owner of the ranch, working alongside characters like Jimmy from the original “Yellowstone.”

While nothing is officially confirmed, most fans—and the author of this analysis—are hoping to see McConaughey in the historical setting of “1944,” bringing his star power and dramatic chops to a new chapter in the Dutton family saga.

Whether he ends up in “1944,” “6666,” or another spin-off, one thing is certain: Matthew McConaughey’s addition to the Yellowstone universe will be a major event, and fans can’t wait to see what role he’ll play.