Fans were heartbroken by the tragic fate of Alexandra Dutton (Julia Schlaepfer) in the Season 2 finale of 1923. After enduring a harrowing journey to reunite with Spencer (Brandon Sklenar) and giving birth to their son, John Dutton II, Alex succumbed to complications, leaving Spencer to raise their child alone. However, Julia Schlaepfer herself, along with co-star Brandon Sklenar, have pitched a creative idea for Alex’s return in Taylor Sheridan’s upcoming prequel, 1944, that could genuinely fit within the Yellowstone universe’s established narrative style.
The Pitch: Alex as a “Ghost” or Narrator in “1944”
In interviews following the 1923 finale, both Julia Schlaepfer and Brandon Sklenar revealed they’ve discussed with Taylor Sheridan the possibility of Alex returning as a “ghost” or spectral presence in 1944. Sklenar charmingly described it as Alex “haunting Spencer in the most beautiful way,” not in a spooky sense, but more like a fun, whispering banter and even playing pranks. Schlaepfer echoed this, confirming it’s a “goal.”
Why This Idea Could Actually Work in 1944
This concept isn’t as far-fetched as it might initially sound, especially within the context of the Yellowstone universe:
-
Established Precedent with Elsa Dutton: The most compelling reason this could work is the precedent set by Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) in 1883 and 1923. Despite her death in 1883, Elsa continued to serve as the powerful and poignant narrator for both prequels, providing crucial context and emotional depth. Alex, having also died tragically but leaving behind the next generation (John Dutton II), could easily step into a similar narrative role for 1944. Her unique perspective as an outsider who bravely embraced the Dutton world would be invaluable.
-
Continuing Spencer’s Emotional Arc: Spencer Dutton’s journey has been defined by loss and trauma. Losing Alex, the love of his life and the mother of his son, would undoubtedly be a profound wound. Having Alex appear to him as a “ghost” or a manifestation of his memories and grief would be a powerful way to continue Spencer’s emotional storyline in 1944. It would allow their beloved love story to persist beyond her physical death, shaping Spencer’s decisions as a father and a Dutton. This would be particularly relevant if 1944 features an older Spencer (Brandon Sklenar has expressed interest in reprising the role, perhaps with makeup to age him) grappling with the responsibilities of raising John Dutton II.
-
Connecting Generations Through Memory: The Yellowstone prequels are all about legacy and the continuous struggle to protect the land. Alex’s sacrifice directly led to the birth of John Dutton II, who will be a central figure in 1944 as a young man. Her spectral presence could serve as a guiding force, a reminder of the sacrifices made for the Dutton lineage, connecting the generations in a profound, spiritual way.
-
Taylor Sheridan’s Penchant for Poetic Storytelling: Taylor Sheridan is known for his poetic and often melancholic storytelling. The idea of a lost love continuing to influence and “haunt” a survivor fits perfectly within his narrative style, adding a layer of profound emotion that audiences have come to expect from the Yellowstoneuniverse.
While specific plot details for 1944 (which will likely center on John Dutton II, who would be in his early 20s during World War II) are still under wraps, the idea of Julia Schlaepfer reprising her role as Alex in a non-corporeal form offers a beautiful and logical way to keep a fan-favorite character and her essential love story alive within the ever-expanding Dutton saga.
