If you think you know the Duttons from their intense stares and dramatic showdowns, think again. In a recent Vanity Fair video, the cast of Yellowstone sat down for a lighthearted “How Well Do You Know Me?” challenge, revealing surprising secrets and sparking plenty of laughs.

The Cast Members: Who’s Who in the Challenge

Before diving into the fun, let’s meet the stars who participated in this revealing game:

• Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton

• Kelly Reilly as Beth Dutton

• Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton

• Cole Hauser as Rip Wheeler

• Kelsey Asbille as Monica Dutton

• Gil Birmingham as Thomas Rainwater

• Jefferson White as Jimmy Hurdstrom

The Game Begins: Questions That Stumped the Cast

The challenge kicked off with a series of personal questions that had the cast members scratching their heads:

1. What Was My Childhood Pony’s Name?

When asked about his childhood pony, Luke Grimes was stumped. After some playful guesses, the answer was revealed: “Cinnamon.” Grimes admitted, “I never would’ve guessed.”

2. What Sport Did I Play Professionally Before Acting?

Wes Bentley surprised everyone by revealing he played soccer professionally before his acting career. The revelation left his co-stars in awe, with one remarking, “I didn’t know that.”

3. Who Do I Get Mistaken For Most Often?

Wes Bentley shared that he’s frequently mistaken for actor Tobey Maguire. His co-stars had a good-natured laugh, with one adding, “You’re more handsome than him.”

Hidden Talents: The Duttons’ Secret Skills

The game also uncovered some unexpected talents among the cast:

1. Cole Hauser’s Dance Moves

Known for his tough-guy persona as Rip Wheeler, Cole Hauser revealed he’s actually a skilled dancer. His co-stars were taken aback, with one joking, “Maybe in my twenties.”

2. Jefferson White’s Rodeo Skills

Jefferson White, who portrays Jimmy Hurdstrom, admitted he had never ridden a horse before joining the show. His dedication to learning the ropes was evident, as he spent days practicing to portray his character authentically.

Behind the Scenes: The Cast’s Off-Screen Bonds

Beyond the laughs and surprises, the challenge highlighted the strong camaraderie among the cast members. Kelsey Asbille, who plays Monica Dutton, shared that the cast enjoys spending time together off-screen, often hanging out between takes and supporting each other during filming.

The Final Score: Who Knows Who Best?

After a series of questions and playful banter, the scores were tallied. Luke Grimes emerged as the winner, correctly answering five out of ten questions. However, the true victory was the laughter and bonding shared among the cast members.

Conclusion: More Than Just Co-Stars

The “How Well Do You Know Me?” challenge offered fans a rare glimpse into the personal lives and personalities of the Yellowstone cast. While their on-screen characters are embroiled in drama and conflict, off-screen, they share genuine friendships and a sense of humor that adds depth to their performances.