The epic saga of 1923 might have wrapped up, but don’t get too comfortable—the story is far from over. While the conclusion of Season 2 seemed like a series finale packed with closure, drama, and emotional farewells, the truth is that the Yellowstone universe is only just beginning to unravel new secrets and mysteries, especially as we prepare for what’s being dubbed the spiritual Season 3—set in 1944.

After two years of globe-trotting, heartache, and intense battles for survival, fans were finally gifted with Spencer Dutton’s long-awaited return to Montana. But was it all worth it? Spencer’s showdown with Donald may have delivered cinematic flair, but many are questioning whether it really needed his heroics. The ranch could’ve likely been defended without him, making his storyline feel a bit… underwhelming.

And then there’s Alexandra. Her tragic death left fans in tears—and disbelief. After enduring so much, her sudden demise felt like a cruel twist rather than a narrative payoff. But Spencer’s journey doesn’t end with her. In a shocking revelation, we learn he fathers a child with a widow—though never marries her. This mysterious relationship will be explored in 1944, potentially tying Spencer’s bloodline to Yellowstone’s very own Jamie Dutton. Yes, a war over inheritance and Dutton legitimacy might be brewing.

As for Elizabeth and Jack, their story was perhaps even more heartbreaking. Elizabeth, pregnant and emotionally shattered, was brushed aside by the Duttons, especially Cara. Fans are furious over the cold treatment she received—especially since her child could carry on the Dutton legacy. This ignored plotline may find its resolution in The Madison, another upcoming series, rumored to follow Elizabeth and Jack’s descendants returning to Montana.