🩺 A Secret Almost Hidden
In the tense ITV‑aired Casualty miniseries Internal Affairs, one storyline sent ripples through Holby ED when a beloved character is revealed to have nearly committed medical misconduct—and almost gotten away with it. The drama centers on Dr Ethan Hardy, who, in a moment of personal vengeance, allows a notorious criminal to die under his care.

Who Is the “He”?
The man at the centre of the storm is Ethan Hardy (George Rainsford)—a character largely defined by empathy and professionalism until now. Facing the convicted criminal Scott Ellisson, who was responsible for injuring Ethan’s brother and causing his own life-changing trauma, Ethan sees an opportunity. Rather than saving Scott’s life when he arrives injured in the ED, Ethan deliberately fails to intervene, allowing the patient to die. What makes matters worse is that he tries to conceal his actions—or at least delay scrutiny.

From the patient’s perspective, the failure is subtle—no overt weapon, just a decision to prolong suffering rather than intervene. But for those sensitive enough to notice, the omission is damning.

The Cover-Up and Suspicion
In the immediate aftermath, Ethan appears unfazed. He continues treating other emergencies as if nothing happened. Internally, Ethan wrestles with guilt—but externally, he behaves like nothing is wrong. That is, until questions start arising from colleagues, including fellow medical staff like Alicia Munroe and others who remember prior allegations of negligence surrounding Scott.

Ethan’s attempt to evade internal scrutiny is initially successful—his in-action is hard to prove without a clear medical incident. The suspense is masterfully executed, with Internal Affairs only gradually closing in on the facts. As fans on Casualty forums put it: Ethan truly “nearly got away with it.”
Fallout Inside the ED
As Internal Affairs looks deeper into Scott Ellisson’s death, colleagues begin to sense that something isn’t right. Flashes of discomfort from Ethan during routine procedures, small behavioural slips, and inconsistencies in notes begin to paint a worrying picture. Alicia Munroe grows suspicious, recalling how Scott should have been treated—and Ethan should have saved him. Evidence becomes thicker, and Internal Affairs starts to loom.

Ethan’s world begins to unravel. The clinical lead must decide whether to protect his own colleagues or accept accountability. The stakes: not just his career, but potentially criminal prosecution if negligence can be proven.

A Moral Crisis and a Legal One
Over weeks of episodes, viewers witness Ethan spiral emotionally. The guilt intensifies: he issues fewer orders, hesitates during emergencies, and hesitates under pressure. Despite the pressure, however, the ED must carry on—a metaphor for the NHS under strain. Meanwhile, Internal Affairs edges closer.

Eventually, the investigation concludes there is no criminal case—Ethan’s actions are deemed “not intentional murder,” but career-ending negligence is still a threat. He’s removed from the ED and forced to face consequences.

Fan Reaction: Guilty or Justified?
On social media and Reddit, fans vividly debated the storyline:

“Ethan letting that criminal die was dark—but understandable given what he did to his brother. I didn’t want him arrested, but I can’t blame Internal Affairs.”
Mwnews

“They legit almost ruined his career… but it felt more moral crisis than coldness.”

Some viewers described the arc as Internal Affairs’ most shocking twist yet, thanks to the nuance of portraying a normally ethical character doing something indefensible—and nearly escaping detection.

How It Fits Into “Internal Affairs” Series Themes
Set against broader themes of corruption, workplace ethics, and personal crisis, the Ethan storyline stands out. Other plotlines—such as Rida Amaan’s workplace abuse by surgeon Whitelaw, Ngozi Okoye’s struggle with alcoholism, and Stevie Nash’s stalker trauma—all underline how power and secrets within the hospital can shatter lives.
Ethan’s arc adds a chilling dimension: sometimes the enemy is not external—but the person who swore to save lives.

What’s Next for Ethan?
Though he escapes criminal prosecution, the consequences are severe. Career suspension seems likely; returning to frontline work is uncertain. Some fans have speculated he may seek psychiatric help or attempt to rebuild his professional reputation—if he can find forgiveness within himself and among colleagues.

Meanwhile, other characters—like Alicia or Dylan Keogh—may intervene. Some think Internal Affairs may extend into a broader probe of ED culture and decision-making. Ethan’s survival, emotionally or professionally, now hinges on confession or redemption storyline yet to unfold.

A Story Told With Precision
The writing and pacing were praised for restraint. Unlike sudden meltdowns or dramatic reveals, Ethan’s misconduct was understated—a misstep executed in a subtle moment of suppressed grief. That realism helped the storyline resonate.

Fans on Reddit described Episode 8 (“Internal Affairs” boxset) as the turning point, with Ethan’s moral collapse slowly becoming visible before the investigation brings it to light. Though not the flashiest story in Casualty’s history, many called it one of the most powerful.