Buried Bodies and Deadly Secrets: Emmerdale’s Double-Murder Conspiracy Could Seal John Sugden’s Fate

The quiet lanes of Emmerdale are anything but peaceful these days. Two brutal deaths, one man under suspicion, and an entire village holding its breath. As Emmerdale dives headfirst into a murder mystery saga, viewers are bracing themselves for the downfall of John Sugden — but could he be about to take the fall for two murders?

Yes, you read that right. With Nate Robinson’s body freshly pulled from the lake, suspicions are rapidly circling around John. And fans are now speculating that he could also be framed for the earlier, unresolved death of Anthony Fox. But is it justice… or a colossal cover-up?

❗ Recap: Anthony Fox – Murder or Misdirection?

Months ago, Anthony Fox’s lifeless body was seemingly left at the Depot. Bloodied, with a tooth on the floor, it was a grizzly scene. At the time, viewers saw Aaron lash out in a furious attack after learning Anthony had abused Ruby Miligan. Aaron believed he’d killed him in the heat of the moment.

Then came John Sugden.

Stepping into the scene, John took control, disposing of Anthony’s body without hesitation. To this day, no one knows where that body is — though it’s definitely not under a tree trunk, despite fan theories.

But the real shocker came later: Ruby, emotionally wrecked and seeking revenge, had returned after Aaron left and finished the job — suffocating Anthony to death herself.

🧩 Nate’s Death Reopens Every Wound

Just as the village began to move on, the discovery of Nate’s body changed everything. A full-scale investigation was launched, and suspicion quickly fell on multiple characters — including Tracy, Aaron, and of course, John.

But viewers already know the truth: John killed Nate, coldly and intentionally.

Now, with the police digging into his whereabouts and motives, fans believe the inevitable is coming. However, some viewers are predicting an even darker twist…

Could the police discover Anthony’s body — and pin that murder on John too?

🔍 Fans Theorize: Double Homicide, One Scapegoat

The Emmerdale subreddit has been buzzing with speculation. One fan wrote:

“I think that Anthony’s body will eventually be found disposed of in a similar manner + materials to Nate’s, so that when it’s all said and done and John is exiting the soap, the police will count it in with the crimes that John has done.”

Another added:

“I don’t think it’s over yet. I think either the body will turn up at the same time it’s all unraveling for John, or it will turn out that Anthony is still alive.”

Still, the consensus seems clear: fans are expecting a twist — either John goes down for both murders, or Anthony somehow reappears in a dramatic return-from-the-dead arc. And honestly, with Emmerdale, either is plausible.

🔥 What Happens to Ruby?

Perhaps the juiciest layer of this murder sandwich is Ruby Miligan’s involvement. While John might be the obvious villain in Nate’s case, Ruby is the true killer of Anthony — and she’s walking free.

If Anthony’s body is ever found, could new forensic evidence link it back to Ruby? Could Aaron’s original confession come into play? Or will she let John take the fall for her crime?

For now, Ruby has the upper hand. But secrets in Emmerdale rarely stay buried — especially ones with blood on them.

😬 What’s Next?

Next week’s episodes promise further questioning, more red herrings, and rising tension among the villagers. John’s cage is clearly rattling — but will he confess? Will Ruby be exposed? Or is there an even bigger twist coming?

One thing’s for sure: Emmerdale is entering one of its most thrilling murder arcs in years. With bodies buried, suspects spiraling, and fan theories flying, the drama is at full boil. And we’re absolutely here for it. 🍿