Emmerdale fans were recently left reeling — and excited — by the return of Robert Sugden, whose unexpected appearance at Aaron Dingle and John’s wedding set tongues wagging and emotions running high. After years away and a stint in prison, Robert’s comeback was short-lived, but it stirred up far more than old feelings. Now, with whispers of a permanent return on the horizon, viewers are asking one heart-wrenching question: Does Robert even know that Liv Flaherty is dead?

Robert’s surprise entrance came on what should have been a joyful day — Aaron’s wedding. But when the man he once called the love of his life showed up uninvited, emotions boiled over fast. Aaron, stunned and conflicted, punched Robert in a burst of shock and anger. Then, in a moment of raw vulnerability, the two shared a kiss. It was brief, intense, and enough to shake Aaron to his core — but ultimately, he chose to go through with the wedding to John.

As Aaron and John exchanged vows, Robert was left on the sidelines, emotionally gutted and alone. Before he could even leave the village and lick his wounds, PC Swirling arrived and arrested him on the spot. The reason? By choosing to crash the wedding, Robert missed a scheduled probation meeting — a violation that immediately sent him back to prison.

But don’t worry, Robron fans — that wasn’t the end. It’s now been confirmed that Robert is set to return to Emmerdale permanently, promising even more drama, unresolved emotions, and possibly a Robron reunion. However, his reappearance raises a deeply emotional question: Is Robert even aware that Liv is gone?

Liv Flaherty wasn’t just a relative or acquaintance to Robert — she was family. As Aaron’s half-sister, Liv became an integral part of Robron’s storyline. Their shared scenes were heartfelt and meaningful, with Robert often acting as a protective, brotherly figure to the young woman. The bond between them was a fan-favorite dynamic, affectionately dubbed “Roblivion” by viewers who cherished their connection.

But Liv tragically died while Robert was behind bars — and his return has so far included no mention of her, no reaction, no mourning. It’s this silence that has left fans unsettled, flooding social media with concerns and speculations.

“Do we think Robert knows Liv is dead??” one fan posted, echoing the question on everyone’s mind. Another pleaded: “We need Robert and Aaron to talk about Liv. She was a huge part of their lives.” Others questioned how Robert could have known about Aaron’s wedding (possibly via social media) but not learned of Liv’s death, especially if he wasn’t given the chance to grieve or receive support at the time.

For some, the idea that Robert might have discovered Liv’s passing on his own — isolated, emotionally raw, and without anyone to comfort him — is unbearable. “No more Roblivion ever,” one fan mourned. Another pointed out the glaring omission of Seb, Robert and Rebecca’s son, and questioned whether his return might help reconnect this broken family.

What makes this absence of acknowledgement particularly poignant is how crucial Liv was to both Aaron and Robert. Her struggles, growth, and eventual tragic end deeply affected Aaron — and fans feel strongly that Robert’s emotional arc isn’t complete without confronting her loss.

With Robert’s permanent return looming, Emmerdale has the perfect opportunity to fill in these emotional gaps. A raw, honest conversation between Aaron and Robert about Liv could not only serve as powerful closure but also reignite a story thread that was left painfully unfinished.

There’s also the question of Seb — Robert’s son — who hasn’t been seen in the village in quite some time. Could the writers be setting up a powerful family reunion storyline? If Robert is returning, will he fight for a place in his son’s life? And will this coincide with him reckoning with the loss of the sister-in-law he once helped raise?

What we do know is that fans are deeply invested in this next chapter. Robert’s return opens the door to long-overdue conversations, unresolved grief, and possibly redemption. The fan base is passionate, particularly when it comes to Robron — and they’re ready to see their favorite characters grapple with the emotional fallout of everything they’ve lost.

As the village prepares for more emotional upheaval, one thing is clear: the ghosts of the past are still haunting Robert Sugden. Whether he knows about Liv yet or not, that truth will eventually come to light — and when it does, it could change everything.