Josh did not treat Natalie like a girlfriend at all. Her biggest gripe was that Josh was not even taking her to see his house in Arizona. Natalie also relied on Josh for financial help. When she realized Josh was not going to give her something she really wanted – a baby – she even asked Mike to take her back. However, Josh and Natalie were involved for about three years and did part ways on The Last Resort season 2 after several arguments and misunderstandings.

What Josh Revealed About His New Girlfriend After Natalie

Josh’s Shocking Confession About His Dating Life

In February 2025, Josh appeared on “The Sarah Fraser Show” podcast, where he confirmed his split with Natalie. Josh added that he was still friends with Natalie and that he still cared for her “a lot” despite the wild ride that their relationship had been. Josh also mentioned that Natalie was dependent on him and considered him her “person to call.” Natalie didn’t have anyone else to turn to during her time of need, and Josh ended up thinking, “Who’s going to be there for her?” if not for him. Josh admitted that this strung their relationship along “a little bit.”

In February 2025, Josh appeared on “The Sarah Fraser Show” podcast, where he confirmed his split with Natalie. Josh added that he was still friends with Natalie and that he still cared for her “a lot” despite the wild ride that their relationship had been. Josh also mentioned that Natalie was dependent on him and considered him her “person to call.” Natalie didn’t have anyone else to turn to during her time of need, and Josh ended up thinking, “Who’s going to be there for her?” if not for him. Josh admitted that this strung their relationship along “a little bit.”

Josh Has Been Linked To Libby Potthast’s Sister, Jenn

Josh & Jenn’s Dating Rumors Explained

90 Day Fiancé fans know Jenn as Elizabeth Potthast’s sister. Josh was first spotted with Jenn (via therealitytvmess) in February 2023. It could have been when Josh and Natalie were on a break in their on-and-off relationship. The video was filmed by Josh at a restaurant where he and Jenn were accompanied by their friends for dinner. Josh flipped the camera to face him and Jenn and raised his drink to the camera as Jenn gently rested her head on his shoulder. Moreover, Jenn also fueled rumors that she was Josh’s new partner.

In March 2025, Shabooty shared photos of Josh at the Las Vegas airport as he was heading to Phoenix. The 90 Day Fiancé blogger mentioned that Josh was accompanied by a mystery woman, hinting she could be his new girlfriend. He also pointed out that Josh was flying with American Airlines in “Group 1,” which could indicate a first-class seat. The woman with Josh also had a small dog in tow. She was blonde and had her hair tied in pigtails. However, the woman’s face was not visible in any of the photos.

Sarah Fraser, who recently had Josh as a guest on her podcast, “The Sarah Fraser Show” dropped an unexpected comment for 90 Day Fiancé fans. She confirmed that the woman in the photos was indeed Josh’s new girlfriend. According to Sarah, Josh had mentioned his new relationship on her podcast, and the woman was going to make an appearance on the upcoming Tell All episodes, suggesting that Josh will introduce her during the 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 Tell All.

I Think Josh Is Dating A Crew Member From The Last Resort Set

Sarah’s claims were confirmed when 90 Day Fiancé posted a preview for the upcoming The Last Resort Tell All. In the video, host Shawn Robinson directed a question to Josh while filming, asking if he had started seeing anyone else. Josh responded, “Well, you know, I do like someone. A lot. We’ve been spending a lot of time together,” as Natalie looked on, clearly displeased. Shawn then told the cameras that they had “actually” extended an invitation to the new woman Josh has been seeing for the Tell All.